When council rate relief is bad

In response to the Coronavirus pandemic, some local councils have announced, or are planning, an across-the-board rate freeze.

A rate freeze is a bad idea for these reasons:

Council rates are a “wealth tax”, not an income tax. Rates are calculated using property values. To quote a council CFO, six out of seven ratepayers are not negatively affected by COVID. A general rate freeze gives a benefit to the maximum number of voters, but most of the relief dollars go to the wealthiest landowners.

Under a general % rates cut or waiver, wealthiest landowners get the most $ relief

Due to rate capping, Victorian councils are already subject to a maximum small percentage increase in total rates collected. A rate freeze lowers rate-raising capacity not just for the current year, but for future years. This will reduce local government services permanently.

A better idea is to target relief, here are some suggestions:

Relief for the most affected in the residential community. Pensioners that are asset rich and income poor. Unemployed property owners. Easier to access financial hardship rate deferments. Increased material aid (food and care) packages.

Rather than grant relief to the wealthiest landowners, it is better to target those most in need.

Increased support for the most affected in the business community. Refund street trading permit charges. Rate rebates for retail traders.

Summary

When the impacts of the pandemic were first known, many councils responded quickly with broad-brush relief. In order for the limited amount of relief to be most effectively and fairly applied, relief should now be targeted to those most in need.

While a rates freeze such as that announced by the City of Melbourne is politically popular, most of the benefit goes to the wealthy, with any resulting debt burden borne by the whole community.

If I use myself as an example, I have experienced no loss of income, as I can do my job working from home. Due to restrictions, there are fewer opportunities to spend money and my bank balance has increased. So I don’t deserve rate relief. I would prefer the genuinely needy receive relief, support, and council services, rather than people that own large amounts of property.

Reference

Greater Dandenong $4 million COVID rate relief

Kingston Council 5% rate and charges discount

Monash Council 10% rate waiver